Soccer Tottenham 1-1 Newcastle: We possess received misplaced the position with handball, says Steve Bruce

Football Tottenham 1-1 Newcastle: We possess got lost the role with handball, says Steve Bruce


MOTD2: ‘Ridiculous’ handball rule has ‘purchased to alter’

Soccer has “misplaced the position” with the distinctive handball ruling and selections made by officers are inflicting Premier League matches to “lose the spectacle”, says Newcastle supervisor Steve Bruce.

The Magpies had been awarded a unhurried penalty after Andy Carroll’s knockdown got here off Eric Dier’s arm inside the field.

Callum Wilson remodeled the 97th-minute situation-kick within the 1-1 plan at Tottenham.

Spurs boss Jose Mourinho did not need to remark however stated there was as quickly as “no admire” for his membership.

‘We possess misplaced the position’ – Bruce on handball and VAR

The hosts led by means of Lucas Moura’s first-half strike however ignored a choice of chances, permitting Newcastle to current a degree with their most interesting shot on path within the contest.

With time figuring out, Jonjo Shelvey floated a free-kick into the residence which change Carroll nodded down however the ball got here off Dier’s outstretched arm – with the defender’s help in route of the ball – as he jumped to make a bid.

Following a prolonged session with the video assistant referee (VAR), on-self-discipline official Peter Bankes awarded the penalty after reviewing the incident on the pitch-side video show.

Jose Mourinho says Spurs ‘deserve further admire’

Mourinho walked down the tunnel in disgust after seeing Wilson ranking the penalty and, when requested to current his response to the selection, he stated: “I do not resolve on to debate it.

“The right feeling I am ready to piece is that I do not really really feel Tottenham is revered per what the membership is. No admire.

“It is my feeling. That you just would possibly nicely very successfully pay attention to it is miles the third membership I really possess managed within the nation, so overjoyed so proud, so overjoyed each day, I’d not trade it for any totally completely different job on the earth however I really really feel it, I really really feel we deserve further admire.”

What has took place this season with handball?

So a ways this season, six penalties had been awarded for handball when put subsequent with 19 within the complete lot of the ultimate marketing campaign. At this stage ultimate season, there had been no penalties awarded for handball within the Premier League.

The essential factor European leagues had been already implementing the distinctive ‘stricter’ interpretation of the handball pointers ultimate season and that resulted in 50 penalties ensuing from handball in La liga and 60 in Serie A.

Bruce added: “The handball has been round for 100 years. If it is deliberate, no discipline, nevertheless it should guarantee and apparent. We possess received misplaced the position with it and it loses the spectacle of it.

“Perhaps we are able to make one factor about it, we seem to own these phases the construct we expend each half truly within the Premier League and most certainly we need to yelp no to it.”

On Saturday, Roy Hodgson stated the “nonsense” handball pointers that resulted in a penalty in opposition to Joel Ward in Crystal Palace’s 2-1 defeat by Everton was as quickly as “ruining the game”.

football Referee Peter Bankes
Referee Peter Bankes reviewed the selection on the pitch-side video show

So what is the distinctive pointers?

A model distinctive interpretation of the handball pointers was as quickly as launched on the beginning of this season. Beneath these distinctive ideas, a participant will most certainly be penalised for handball if:

  • The hand/arm is clearly far from the physique and exterior the “physique line” .
  • The participant clearly leans into the bolt of the ball.
  • The ball travels a ways.
  • The ball touches a hand/arm that’s clearly raised above the shoulder.
  • The participant falls and the hand/arm is extended laterally or vertically far from the physique.
  • A deflection clearly makes no distinction to the ball touching a hand/arm that’s clearly extended far from the physique and/or above the shoulder

‘An absolute comical memoir’ – what the pundits stated

Used Premier League striker Clinton Morrison on BBC Radio 5 Stay: “It is a homely resolution. I’d nicely nicely presumably be going contaminated. VAR is ruining our recreation. It is the rules, I understand, however he is going through totally completely different method. We possess received purchased to be further mounted after we’re making these selections.

“I totally salvage it’s the rules, however you possess gotten purchased to be mounted. Mourinho will most certainly be asking why they did not mediate to ascertain the handball incident with Jamaal Lascelles moments sooner than, which regarded further of a penalty. Dier was as quickly as having a gape totally completely different method.

“It final frustrates me. On the pinnacle of the game I need to chat about soccer. As a change we’re speaking about VAR and the handball rule. I’d expend the handball rule far from the VAR officers.

“I am keen on it that the referee goes to the video show as a result of the gamers will admire it further. I do not blame the referee, I blame VAR. That’s the sector.”

Used Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher on Sky Sports activities actions: “An absolute shame, a comical memoir. Every individual on this nation will negate what I’m saying.

“Dier had no regulate of the construct his arm was as quickly as. Whether or not or not it’s the FA, Fifa, Pierluigi Collina, discontinue it, it is ruining soccer for each individual. An absolute comical memoir.”

Used Newcastle supervisor Graeme Souness: “It is the distinctive ideas. It is harsh however these are the foundations.

“Perhaps it would construct further pleasure and objectives and at ultimate we’re ready to salvage to fetch it.”

‘Salvage our recreation help’ – response on social media

What you stated on #bbcfootball:

Ashley: Sure we would like VAR, however that was as quickly as by no means a handball by Dier. He clearly did not know the construct the ball was as quickly as! Change the rule NOW!

Adam Salter: In all seriousness, unintended handball should aloof not be given as a penalty. Give it the hockey remedy and award an indirect free-kick on the nook of the field on the byline.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here